I've got a fully compensated saddle on my 12 string. Guitar makers set up their instruments according to their own specifications, and any guitar service technician can easily handle either a basic setup or a more customized setup to suit a seasoned player’s preferences and playing technique. Same problems apply. Using public key cryptography with multiple recipients. It can be controlled by tightening or loosening the truss rod, which is located in the neck. Something else to keep in mind is that the closer a string is to the frets, the less it needs to stretch since it doesn’t have as far to go. the B string is often slightly longer than the E and G it neighbours. Why don't acoustic guitars usually have adjustable saddles? What is their role, their effect on the sound ? This is typically found in classic style guitars the reason being that the guitar was set up in a way that a compensated saddle was not required. Very, very unlikely it's ivory! Welcome to r/guitar, a community devoted to the exchange of guitar related information and entertainment. Likewise, many saddles are made with compensation points for some or all of the strings, which helps fine-tune those points even more. (Think of a tuneup for a car or bicycle.) I learned as a newbie on this site that if you don't verify the accuracy of the information you contribute, you will be called out lol. Sign in ... Why don't acoustic guitars usually have adjustable saddles? With musical instruments, intonation refers to pitch accuracy—the extent to which the notes formed are in tune, versus being flat or sharp. Intonation issues can be subtle or dramatic depending on a guitar’s setup. For most of us playing between 1 and 12 a well compensated one piece saddle is the best compromise and works just fine, thank you. What is the best way to remove 100% of a software that is not yet installed? You can post now and register later. Our expert staff is ready to assist you, Join the Taylor family and enjoy exclusive owner benefits, Tap into our network of Taylor-certified repair technicians. Archived. 16. Due to each string being a different density, and gauge, each one needs its own speaking length, which when adjusted accurately will make each fretted note sound better in tune. Did it get a good rep or did the saddles really take away from the sound? People are being unhelpful, but the key is how electrics and acoustics make sound in different ways. As you play fretted notes closer to the bridge, the effect of the stretching increases due to a sharper deflection angle. Looks a bit like a rip saw blade but intonation is as good as it gets all the way up. At Taylor, we have the added benefit of our proprietary neck design, which ensures that every guitar is built with proper action and accurate nut and saddle location. The design of the saddle and bridge assembly found on acoustic guitars is able to more effectively transfer the vibration of the strings to the soundboard. @Tim Answering this question inspired me to look at the fixed saddle on my Taylor T-5 12 string guitar which comes pre-strung with plain steel G string vs. wound G String. This is a real answer. What is a "hybrid" audio interface anyway? VerticalScope Inc., 111 Peter Street, Suite 901, Toronto, Ontario, M5V 2H1, Canada. Re: Intonatable saddles on acoustic guitars? There are, of course, some gits with two piece saddles in an attempt to get the intonation better. This is why almost all steel string acoustic guitars will have a slanted saddle that makes the heavier strings longer. Just like Homepathy, the power of suggestion, confirmation bias, placebo response is strong and if someone in a white lab coat and a nametag that says "Dr. Smith" hands them a sugar pill and tells them it will help them sleep, the next morning, they will wake up and insist the pill worked great. If you have guitar related questions, use the "Search" field or ask the community. Essentially the top is now more in tune with the strings. We experience that chaos as dissonance, the beating or wavering sound that occurs when you play a chord voicing that the acoustic guitar isn’t built to reproduce accurately. Essentially, the technician is trying to get everything right before actually adjusting the acoustic guitar’s intonation. Reply to this topic; Start new topic; Recommended Posts. I'm puzzled by the little staggered stuffs etched in the saddles of most of my acoustic guitars. Clear editor. I guess it just goes to show how deeply-held some of those stupid beliefs are. http://www.google.co.uk/patents/US5814745, Re: The All-New Behringer Keyboards 'n' Stuff Thread. The technician will check the guitar’s action (the distance between the strings and the fretboard), as well as the instrument’s neck relief. The saddle and bridge of an acoustic guitar are made to conduct vibration from the strings into the soundboard, thus making it...sound. The guy who is still reading War and Peace. Why don't acoustic guitars usually have adjustable saddles? Do other planets and moons share Earth’s mineral diversity? This must be done due to the wider arc produced by the heavier wound strings when they vibrate. The bass strings which sit higher off the fretboard will get an added sharpening effect due to the greater distance they must be stretched to reach the frets. How to solve this puzzle of Martin Gardner? everyone complains about, say, a three-barrel Telecaster bridge being impossible to set up correctly, but most acoustics. Believe me, NOT the same thing at all.   Your previous content has been restored. This is why most acoustic will vary in saddle design as a compensated saddle does not fit all guitars as each guitar have different playing conditions as the design ... As not all guitars need compensating (if it ain’t broke don’t fix it). Your answer made me get a glimpse of the issue. Where is this Utah triangle monolith located? rev 2020.11.24.38066, The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Music: Practice & Theory Stack Exchange works best with JavaScript enabled, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site, Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, Learn more about hiring developers or posting ads with us, It's not clear (to me) what the picture shows. Why my diagonal dots become 6 dots rather than 3? Why Is an Inhomogenous Magnetic Field Used in the Stern Gerlach Experiment? site design / logo © 2020 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa. Many things must be considered when designing the optimal shape and contours of an acoustic guitar saddle. Mine does! In general, the thicker strings are longer. “Question closed” notifications experiment results and graduation, MAINTENANCE WARNING: Possible downtime early morning Dec 2/4/9 UTC (8:30PM…. I recall having read somewhere that Gibson experimented with adjustable saddles on acoustics much like the electrics they made, but it didn't work out too well, something about having heavy metal parts on the soundboard damping its vibrations. To understand why, consider the difference between how an electric guitar produce sufficient sound volume vs an acoustic. Thus, acoustic builders are more intense about that connection, and the materials involved. Older guitars have straight saddles and classic guitars… The 1960's Gibson Doves had an adjustable bridge. Once they're bent, when you turn them with a screwdriver, the saddle will rock back and forth. But as it turns out, the top movement also plays an important role in the intonation. Display as a link instead, × Why is the battery turned off for checking the voltage on the A320? Generally the thicker strings need to be "compensated" more (made longer) because the larger the diameter of the string, the more tension needed to stretch it down to reach the frets and the more the pitch is altered by the stretching of the string. For guitarists who record or play music live, intonation problems can ruin a recording session or a live performance. The bridge makes very solid contact with the soundboard and the saddle sits in a slot in the bridge, allowing it to contact the bridge on both sides of the saddle as well as the bottom. More likely plastic - or bone. It is thicker than the core of the wound G string and the high e string, so it should be longer than either of the strings beside it. You may login with either your assigned username or your e-mail address. Additionally: An old luthier told me that the thinner-cored strings 'bend' as they vibrate nearly at the point of contact with the saddle, whereas thicker cored strings start their bend a little further away from the saddle, hence the need for a little more length.